Oceanic Island Colonization

Oceanic islands have never been connected to continental landmasses and represent some of the most isolated environments on earth. Extensive stretches of deep ocean surrounding such islands represent formidable dispersal filters and they receive their biotas solely through dispersal from geographically distant source populations and from subsequent in situ diversification. This feature of their natural history makes oceanic islands ideal habitats to test long-distance dispersal hypotheses for benthic shallow-water marine taxa. For instance, a traditional paradigm in marine biology has been that an extended pelagic larval phase is a prerequisite to effective long-distance range extension in sedentary benthic invertebrate taxa.

The figure at right (top) shows the rugged eastern coastline of Madeira, a subtropical oceanic island in the eastern North Atlantic. Its one of Diarmaid Ó Foighil's study sites for a research project which aims to discover how a marine clam, Lasaea, successfully colonized numerous oceanic islands in the North Atlantic. The genus Lasaea is composed of minute, crevice-dwelling, intertidal clams that have a near-cosmopolitan distribution on rocky shores. North Atlantic lineages are exclusively composed of direct-developers, i.e., they completely lack pelagic larval development. See picture at right (below) of adults (reddish dots) with a penny for scale.

Predicted phylogenetic tree topologies were generated for 4 competing dispersal hypotheses that seek to explain how direct-developing Lasaea lineages have colonized the Bermudan, Azorean and Madeiran archipelagoes from putative continental source populations in North America (upstream source) and/or Europe (downstream source). See view of the North Atlantic below indicating sampling sites for this study.

Gene trees were constructed for a variety of target genes (>400 individuals sequenced to-date) and these lead to a number of important novel conclusions. Although considered to be a single species by systematists, North Atlantic Lasaea contain highly divergent lineages. Our data indicate that geographical proximity to continental source populations is a better predictor of phylogenetic relationships than present-day oceanic surface circulation patterns. The phylogenetic trees generated are not consistent with colonization of oceanic islands by indirect-developing ancestral lineages or by truly trans-oceanic rafting events. However, they are consistent with predicted topologies resulting from limited (<2,000 km) long-distance colonization by rafting (against prevailing present-day circulation patterns in the case of the Azores/Madeira). Our results further indicate that differentially effective dispersal filters may exist downstream of the Azorean and Madeiran archipelagos and that evidence for countercurrent migration in marine populations should be assessed in light of the totality of surface flow patterns in the study system, not merely the prevailing one.

Perhaps the most surprising result was obtained with the western North Atlantic samples. Phylogenetic analysis yielded a starlike parsimony network within which the mainland (Florida) lineages clustered in one of the terminal branches of a predominantly Bermudan clade; a mirror image of a priori expectations based on regional surface current polarity. Because of their reduced biotic diversity, oceanic islands may allow some taxa to escape competitive interactions that severely reduce survivorship in other parts of their geographic range and, remarkably, our results indicate that Bermuda may represent such an ecological release for western Atlantic Lasaea lineages.

Salient publications:

Ó Foighil, D., R. Jennings, J.K. Park, D.A. Merriwether. 2001. Phylogenetic Relationships of Mid-Oceanic Ridge and Continental Lineages of Lasaea (Mollusca: Bivalvia) in the Northeastern Atlantic. Marine Ecology Progress Series 213:165-175. Click here for abstract.

Park, J.K. and D. Ó Foighil. 2000. Genetic diversity of oceanic island Lasaea (Mollusca: Bivalvia) lineages exceeds that of continental populations in the Northwestern Atlantic. Biological Bulletin 198:396-403. Click here for abstract.

Taylor, D.J. and D. Ó Foighil. 2000. Transglobal comparisons of nuclear and mitochondrial genetic structure in a marine polyploid clam (Lasaea, Lasaeidae).Heredity 84:321-330. Click here for abstract.

Ó Foighil, D. and C.J. Jozefowitz. 1999. Amphi-Atlantic phylogeography of direct-developing lineages of Lasaea, a genus of brooding bivalves. Marine Biology 135:115-122. Click here for abstract.